Law edition and scope

This explainer uses World Rugby’s 2026 Laws of the Game, checked against its online laws on 14 November 2026, for standard 15-a-side rugby union. The edition is identified by the rulebook itself; the review date is not an assumed commencement date. Competition-specific variations are outside this page’s scope. World Rugby 2026 rulebook.

A failed interception is not automatically deliberate

The distinction is between an intentional forward knock with the hand or arm, penalised under Law 11.3, and a failed catch that meets Law 11.4: the player was trying to catch the ball and had a realistic prospect of obtaining possession. An accidental knock-forward normally brings a scrum. World Rugby Law 11.

For the general knock-forward explanation, see lineouts and knock-ons.

What makes an interception attempt realistic?

World Rugby’s deliberate-knock-on guidance asks officials to assess the prospect of catching and securing the ball, then judge the sanction. It expressly rejects a fixed yellow-card formula. January 2023 application guideline, deliberate knock-ons.

As an illustration of that judgement, ask whether the defender could gather the pass from their position and movement, or merely reach it to disrupt it. These are explanatory questions, not an official checklist. Counting hands alone does not answer the possession question: a one-handed attempt is not automatically deliberate, and reaching with two hands does not automatically establish a realistic catch.

Illustrative decisions under World Rugby 2026 Laws 11.1, 11.3 and 11.4
ScenarioAssessmentDecision
A defender moves into the pass, attempts a realistic catch, but spills it forward onto the ground.The attempt satisfies Law 11.4.Accidental knock-forward: normally a scrum.
A defender stretches one hand towards a pass and knocks it forward onto the ground.One hand alone does not establish whether possession was realistically available.Apply Law 11.4 to the actual attempt; do not decide from hand count.
A defender deliberately slaps a pass forward solely to stop it reaching an attacker.An intentional forward knock, rather than an attempt to secure possession.Penalty under Law 11.3; assess any additional sanction separately.

Does deliberate always mean a yellow card?

No. Deciding that the knock-forward was deliberate establishes the penalty offence; the card assessment remains a further decision. World Rugby’s guidance requires judgement rather than an automatic card formula. Deliberate-knock-on guidance.

Intentional infringement is also addressed by Law 9.7(a). In standard fifteens, a yellow card suspends the player for ten minutes; a subsequent yellow-card offence requires dismissal under Law 9.29. World Rugby Law 9. See sin-bin and red-card rules for the wider disciplinary explanation.

When can the decision become a penalty try?

A deliberate knock-forward does not itself prove that a try was prevented. Law 8.3 requires foul play to have prevented a probable try, or a try in a better position. A penalty try is worth seven points, with no conversion; the responsible player must receive a yellow card or be sent off. World Rugby Laws 8.1(c) and 8.3.

Illustrative scenario: a pass to an unmarked winger. A defender deliberately bats the pass forward near the try line. If the referee judges that the winger would probably have scored without that infringement, the penalty-try test is met.

Illustrative scenario: effective covering defence. The same deliberate action occurs, but another defender is positioned to contest the receiver’s run. That evidence matters when assessing whether a try was probable. Neither proximity to the line nor a numerical overlap decides the question alone. These are applications of the probability test, not additional law thresholds.

See penalty tries for the full explanation.

Related decisions

Continue with advantage, penalty kicks and free kicks, or the rugby union hub.

Primary governing-body sources