Draft review hold: Six Nations edition evidence required

This proposal is incomplete. The official men’s Six Nations rules page supplies the standings provisions but does not identify their effective season. Obtain season-specific governing regulations or an authoritative confirmation before assigning a year and completing this comparison. An access date is not an effective date.

The other basis is explicitly the Rugby World Cup France 2023 Tournament Rules. Its provisions are historical. Keep this proposal a draft.

What the distinction means

These are competition standings regulations, separate from laws governing play. The practical distinction is the order of the tiebreakers: a better overall scoring margin cannot automatically override a decisive head-to-head result in the 2023 World Cup pool process.

Try difference subtracts tries conceded; tries scored does not. Those measures must not be interchanged when calculating a table.

Scope and related explanations

The comparison concerns senior men’s competitions. It does not establish rules for women’s or age-group tournaments. Ordinary completed matches are the focus; cancellation, abandonment and disciplinary outcomes require their own provisions. World Cup knockout matches are outside this pool-table comparison.

For separate laws-of-play explanations, see penalty tries and match timing and stoppage time. These related pages are not evidence of the historical competition regulations.

Governing sources

Rules side by side

Rules side by side
Situation Six Nations Rugby · Undated men's Championship Rules; named season and effective edition unresolved · Men's Six Nations championship standings. Verified text of the official rules page, not verified applicability to a particular season. Editorial completion remains blocked.World Rugby / Rugby World Cup Limited · Rugby World Cup France 2023 — Tournament Rules, section 5 · Senior men's Rugby World Cup 2023 pool-phase match points and final pool rankings. Historical tournament regulations; not a statement of current or future World Cup rules.
Ordinary match result: shared points systemChampionship: win 4, draw 2, loss 0 before bonuses.2023 pool phase: win 4, draw 2, loss 0 before bonuses.
Match bonuses: shared thresholdsChampionship: 1 for scoring at least four tries; 1 for losing by seven points or fewer. Both can be earned together.2023 pool phase: the same two thresholds apply, and both bonuses can be earned together.
Clean-sweep bonusChampionship: winning all five matches adds 3 Grand Slam points.2023 pool phase: no additional clean-sweep bonus appears in the match-points system.
First test when table points are equalFinal championship standings: compare points scored minus points conceded across all championship matches.Final 2023 pool standings: first use the tied teams' head-to-head result; next compare points difference across all pool matches.
Further tiebreakersFinal championship standings: after points difference, compare tries scored, including penalty tries. If still equal, share the position.Final 2023 pool standings: after points difference, compare try difference, then points scored, then tries scored; finally use World Rugby rankings dated 2 October 2023.
Three or more teams tiedFinal championship standings: the published order also covers ties involving more than two teams.Final 2023 pool standings: after identifying the highest team, restart the criteria at head-to-head to determine the next highest.

Rule editions and sources

  • Six Nations Rugby · Undated men's Championship Rules; named season and effective edition unresolved · Men's Six Nations championship standings. Verified text of the official rules page, not verified applicability to a particular season. Editorial completion remains blocked. — Guinness Men's Six Nations — Championship Rules
  • World Rugby / Rugby World Cup Limited · Rugby World Cup France 2023 — Tournament Rules, section 5 · Senior men's Rugby World Cup 2023 pool-phase match points and final pool rankings. Historical tournament regulations; not a statement of current or future World Cup rules. — Rugby World Cup France 2023 — Tournament Rules