Continuation starts with the shooting motion—not the whistle.
Published
Under the 2025–26 NBA Official Rules, a made basket can count when a defender fouls the ball handler after the player has begun the act of shooting and the player completes that same legal shot. On a jump shot, the ball must have started upward toward the basket. On a drive or other moving shot, the player must have gathered the ball and continued through with the shot. Contact before that point is ordinarily a non-shooting foul, so a shot begun afterward does not count.
Quick ruling: freeze the play at the illegal contact. Under NBA Rule 4, Section XI, ask whether the ball was already moving upward on a jump shot or, on a drive, whether the player had gathered and was continuing into the shot. If yes, administer the shooting result: count a legal make and award one free throw, or award two or three free throws for a miss. If no, the whistle makes the ball dead and a later release is not continuation.
Scope
The governing rule used here
This page applies the NBA 2025–26 Official Rules, the latest NBA rulebook published as of 26 August 2026. The controlling provisions are Rule 4, Sections III and XI (gather and field-goal attempt), Rule 6, Section IV (dead ball), Rule 12B, Sections I and V–VIII (personal-foul outcomes), and Rule 14 (Coach's Challenge).
This is an NBA ruling, not a universal basketball ruling. It does not govern WNBA, NCAA, NFHS, FIBA or local play. A current FIBA comparison appears below because its start test is materially different.
Core distinction
“Continuation” is an outcome, not a separate foul
The NBA rulebook uses “continuation” in Rule 14's review provisions, but the on-court decision is built from other rules. The official first decides whether illegal contact occurred and then whether the offensive player had begun the defined shooting motion. The basket remains alive only if the player completes the shot that was already underway.
Contact time, not whistle sound: the decisive comparison is between the illegal contact and the start of shooting motion. The whistle necessarily follows the event the official observed; it does not move a pre-shot foul into the act of shooting.
Jump shots
Possession and a set position are not enough
For a jump shot, NBA Rule 4, Section XI starts the shooting motion when the offensive player begins bringing the ball upward toward the basket. Catching the ball, turning, lowering it, or holding it in a shooting pocket does not by itself satisfy that test.
A defender who illegally hits the player before the upward movement has committed a non-shooting personal foul. If the player then raises and releases the ball after the whistle, the later shot is not a live field-goal attempt. If the illegal contact occurs after the upward movement begins, the player need not release the ball to receive a shooting-foul ruling; the rule expressly covers a shooter whose arms are held.
Drives
The gather matters only with a shot that follows
For a drive or other moving shot, NBA Rule 4, Section XI starts the shooting motion when the player gathers the ball and continues through with a shot. Rule 4, Section III defines a gather as gaining enough control to hold, change hands, pass or shoot; putting two hands on a controlled dribble, pausing with a hand under the ball, or cradling it can establish that control.
The gather is therefore necessary evidence, not an automatic shooting foul. If the player gathers, is contacted, and then passes, resumes a dribble, stops for a separate pivot-and-shot, or otherwise does not continue through with the original shot, the play does not satisfy the NBA's drive wording. Legal steps between gather and release can remain part of one moving shot, but a travel, boundary violation or other offensive violation can still invalidate the basket.
Take-foul exception
One NBA situation uses shoulders-up, not gather
Rule 4, Section XI creates an express exception during a transition take-foul situation when the clocks are not expiring: shooting begins when the player's shoulders start upward. Gathering before that movement does not turn the take foul into a shooting foul.
This boundary matters because the categories exclude one another. Under Rule 12B, Section XI, a transition take foul carries one free throw—attempted by any player who was in the game when the foul occurred—plus possession. It is not ordinary continuation. The special shoulders-up exception does not apply when the clocks are expiring.
End of the act
Release is not the end of a shooter's protection
NBA Rule 4, Section XI says the act continues until the shooting motion ceases and the player returns to a normal floor position. A defender can therefore commit a shooting foul by making illegal contact with an airborne shooter after release but before a normal landing.
The field-goal attempt also includes the ball's flight until it becomes dead or is touched by a player. If a live ball is already in flight toward the rim, the NBA says a goal can count even though the whistle sounds or time expires. The clock qualification still matters: the release must beat the game-clock or shot-clock expiry under the applicable timing rule.
Ordinary penalty
Count the make; replace the missed attempt with free throws
For an ordinary defensive personal foul on the shooter, NBA Rule 12B, Section I supplies the familiar outcomes:
Legal two- or three-point shot made: score the field goal and award one free throw.
Two-point shot missed: award the shooter two free throws.
Three-point shot missed: award the shooter three free throws.
Foul before the shooting motion: award a sideline throw-in if the defensive team is not in the penalty; if it is in the penalty, award the NBA's two penalty free throws.
The penalty situation does not add another bonus free throw to a successful field goal. Rule 12B, Section V caps the same team's scoring at three points on a successful two-point attempt and four on a successful three-point attempt.
What can override it
A shooting motion does not legalise the rest of the play
Offensive foul: under NBA Rule 12B, Section VII, an offensive personal foul means no points for the offensive team and a sideline throw-in for the opponent; no penalty free throws are awarded for an ordinary offensive foul.
Offensive violation: a travel, double dribble, boundary violation or expired shot clock can cancel a make even if a defensive foul and gather are also reviewed. Rule 14 expressly allows a review to determine whether a violation occurred after the gather.
Entirely new attempt: a pause and a new shot after the foul is not the shot that was underway at contact. Finishing something after the whistle is not enough.
Special personal foul: flagrant, punching, away-from-the-play, clear-path and transition-take fouls have separate penalties under Rule 12B. The act-of-shooting test may determine whether a special category is available, but ordinary “and-one” administration should not be assumed.
Time already expired: an ordinary common foul after the horn is disregarded unless the NBA's act-of-shooting exception applies and the shooter released before time expired; unsportsmanlike conduct remains separately punishable.
Separate route
Not every basket-plus-foul is continuation
After a field-goal attempt begins, NBA team control has ended. A defensive loose-ball foul can then be followed by a successful field goal. Rule 12B, Section VIII says the goal may count and the offended player receives one free throw, regardless of which offensive player was fouled and regardless of the penalty situation.
That result can look like continuation on television, but it is analytically different: the foul may be away from the shooter and the loose-ball rule supplies the penalty. Conversely, if the loose-ball foul is against the offensive team and the same offensive player then makes the field goal, the NBA says no points may be scored.
Decision path
How to rule a replay in NBA order
Locate the illegal contact. Use the contact, not the later whistle or release, as the freeze-frame.
Name the play type. Jump shot, drive/moving shot, or transition take-foul situation.
Apply the correct start marker. Ball moving upward for a jump shot; gather plus continuation through the shot for a normal drive; shoulders starting upward for the take-foul exception when clocks are not expiring.
Track the same attempt. Did the player release that shot, get prevented from releasing, or instead pass, dribble or begin a new action?
Check independent defects. Travel, out-of-bounds, offensive foul, shot-clock expiry and goaltending can change the score or restart.
Classify the foul and administer it. Ordinary shooting/non-shooting, loose-ball, flagrant, clear-path or transition take foul do not share one penalty.
Worked case 1
The pull-up has not started upward
Situation: an NBA guard catches, squares to the rim and holds the ball at waist level. A defender illegally hits the guard's arm; only afterward does the guard lift and make a jumper.
NBA 2025–26 ruling: non-shooting foul; no basket. The decisive fact is that Rule 4, Section XI's upward movement had not begun at contact. Apply a sideline throw-in or the penalty free throws according to the team-foul count.
Worked case 2
The gathered drive remains one attempt
Situation: an NBA player gathers a controlled dribble, is fouled on the next legal step, and releases a two-point lay-up without stopping or starting another action.
NBA 2025–26 ruling: the player was in the act of shooting. Count a legal make and award one free throw; if the lay-up misses, award two. Gather plus an uninterrupted continuation through the shot is the decisive fact.
Worked case 3
The gather is followed by a pass
Situation: an NBA driver gathers, is held, takes a legal step and passes to a teammate instead of shooting.
NBA 2025–26 ruling: treat the contact as non-shooting for this drive analysis. The gather alone is insufficient because the player did not “continue through with a shot.” Use a throw-in or penalty free throws according to the team-foul count.
Worked case 4
The ball is released before landing contact
Situation: an NBA three-point shooter releases in time. Before the shooter returns to a normal floor position, the defender makes illegal landing-space contact and the ball enters the basket.
NBA 2025–26 ruling: score three points and award one free throw, provided no separate violation invalidates the goal. The shooting act continues through the return to a normal floor position.
Review
Continuation cannot be challenged by itself
NBA Rule 14 does not let a coach challenge “continuation” as a standalone event. A team may challenge an eligible called event—most relevantly, a personal foul charged to its own team. Once that challenge is properly triggered, the crew chief may review continuation matters, including whether the foul preceded the shooting motion, whether an offensive violation followed the gather, and whether a disallowed make was legal continuation.
The distinction has a practical cost. If the same foul remains charged to the same defender but review changes it only from shooting to non-shooting, Rule 14 treats the challenge as unsuccessful. The team loses the timeout used for that challenge.
FIBA comparison
FIBA 2024 requires control and shooting motion on a drive
The currently effective FIBA Official Basketball Rules 2024 v1.0a, valid from 1 October 2024, should not be reduced to the NBA gather formula. Under FIBA Article 15.1.2, an ordinary act of shooting starts when the player begins moving the ball upward toward the basket. For a drive or other moving shot, Article 15.1.3 requires both that the ball has come to rest in the player's hands after the dribble or an airborne catch and that the player begins the shooting motion preceding release.
FIBA Article 15.1.4 says the number of legal steps is unrelated to whether the act has started. Article 15.1.6 also resolves a useful edge case expressly: if the fouled player passes the ball, that player is no longer considered to have been in the act of shooting. For an ordinary personal foul, Article 34.2 gives the same basic scoring administration—make plus one, or two/three free throws for a miss—but the start test must be FIBA's.
Published but not yet effective: FIBA has published Official Basketball Rules 2026 v1.1, valid from 1 October 2026. Until that date, the Resource Hub separately labels the 2024 book as current. The new Article 15.1.2 will start jump shots and other moving shots when the player moves both the shoulders and ball upward toward the basket. New Article 15.1.3 will treat drives separately: the player must gather, the ball must come to rest in the hands, and the player must continue the shooting motion. New Article 15.1.4 will normally require the shooter to be in the frontcourt, with a last-action exception before game-clock or shot-clock expiry. Those future tests must not be applied to games still governed by FIBA 2024.
Common mistakes
Five shortcuts that produce the wrong answer
“The whistle came before release.” Release is not the start marker; the contact may have occurred during an already active shooting motion.
“Two hands means two shots.” Two hands can establish an NBA gather, but a moving player must still continue through with the shot.
“Upward motion always decides it.” That is the NBA jump-shot marker, the special take-foul marker, and part of the current FIBA analysis—but an ordinary NBA drive normally starts at gather plus continuation through the shot.
“Legal continuation excuses a travel.” It does not. The foul classification and the legality of the scoring attempt are separate questions.
“NBA and FIBA are close enough.” Their drive wording differs, and FIBA has published a revised Article 15 effective 1 October 2026.
Checked on 26 August 2026 against the NBA's 2025–26 rulebook; FIBA 2024 v1.0a rules and interpretations; and the published FIBA 2026 v1.1 book. NBA is the primary scope. FIBA 2024 is current through 30 September 2026, and FIBA 2026 applies from 1 October 2026. NCAA, NFHS, WNBA and local competition rules require separate checking.
Privacy choice
Help us improve Sport Rules
We use Google Analytics to understand which rule explanations are useful. Analytics will not load unless you accept. You can change your choice later in Privacy settings.